Pakistan’s Fuel Protests Are Aimed at the Wrong Villain

Pakistan’s Fuel Protests Are Aimed at the Wrong Villain

Everyone watching the streets of Islamabad, Lahore, and Karachi right now thinks they are witnessing a simple story of economic populism versus state greed. Petrol prices spike. Inflation chokes the middle class. Jamaat-e-Islami mobilizes thousands of demonstrators, shutting down arteries and demanding immediate relief at the pump.

That narrative is lazy, emotionally satisfying, and completely disconnected from macroeconomic reality.

Coverage of Pakistan’s fuel crisis tends to treat high pump prices as an arbitrary punishment inflicted by an indifferent government, while framing street protests as the natural cure. That framing misses the structural mechanics of how energy, currency, and sovereign debt actually work in an import-dependent economy.

Blaming the petroleum levy for Pakistan’s cost-of-living crisis is like blaming a thermometer for a fever. Cutting fuel taxes through street pressure does not make energy cheaper; it simply shifts the bill onto the printing press, accelerates currency collapse, and guarantees that the exact same protestors will pay double for groceries six months later.

The Illusion of the "Cheap Fuel" Demand

Walk into any debate on Pakistani energy policy and you will hear the same demand: slash the Petroleum Development Levy (PDL), scrap the sales tax, and force the state to absorb the global oil shock. Political movements—most visibly Jamaat-e-Islami under Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman—have turned these demands into powerful mobilization tools, rallying traders, transporters, and salaried workers exhausted by shrinking purchasing power.

Their anger is real. When diesel jumps, freight costs explode, turning tomatoes, wheat, and milk into luxury items overnight.

Yet the prescription being demanded in the streets is poison disguised as medicine.

Pakistan imports the vast majority of its crude oil and refined petroleum products. Every liter burned in a motorbike in Rawalpindi or a cargo truck on the N-5 highway requires US dollars to purchase on international markets. The government of Pakistan does not print US dollars. It earns them through exports, remittances, or external borrowing.

When the state artificially suppresses domestic fuel prices below their true import parity cost—either by slashing taxes or offering unfunded subsidies—two things happen immediately:

  1. Consumption stays artificially high. Consumers have zero price signal to conserve an imported resource the country cannot afford.
  2. The fiscal deficit blows wide open. To pay international oil suppliers without collecting revenue at the pump, the Ministry of Finance must borrow from domestic commercial banks or the central bank.

We have already run this exact experiment. In early 2022, an unfunded fuel subsidy freeze burned through hundreds of billions of rupees in a matter of months, derailed an active International Monetary Fund (IMF) program, drained State Bank of Pakistan foreign exchange reserves to perilously low levels, and triggered a historic devaluation of the rupee.

Street protests can force a government to sign an agreement lowering taxes on paper. Street protests cannot conjure foreign exchange reserves out of thin air.

Why the Petroleum Levy Exists in the First Place

To understand why Islamabad clings to high fuel taxes despite fierce political blowback, you have to look at Pakistan’s broken tax architecture.

Pakistan has one of the lowest tax-to-GDP ratios in the region, hovering around 9% to 10%. Vast sectors of the domestic economy—wholesale retail, real estate speculation, and large-scale agriculture—operate largely outside the formal income tax net. Sequential governments have lacked the administrative capacity or political spine to document and tax these untaxed segments directly.

Because the state cannot collect direct taxes from wealthy traders and landlords, it relies on indirect taxes at choke points. Energy is the ultimate choke point.

  • Zero evasion: You cannot hide a tanker of petrol or smuggle electricity without leaving a physical trail at ports and refineries.
  • Immediate collection: The Petroleum Development Levy is collected upfront, providing predictable cash flow to service debt and fund basic state operations.
  • IMF conditionality: Under Pakistan’s Extended Fund Facility agreements with the IMF, maintaining a strict floor on petroleum tax revenue is a non-negotiable benchmark to ensure primary budget surpluses.

Here is the uncomfortable irony of the current protest movement: many of the same trader associations backing strikes against high energy costs have simultaneously resisted retail tax registration schemes like the Tajir Dost initiative. You cannot refuse to pay direct income taxes while simultaneously demanding the state abolish the only indirect taxes it is actually capable of collecting.

What People Get Wrong About Fuel Prices in Pakistan

When people search for answers on why petrol is so expensive in Pakistan, the standard explanations blame corruption, IMF dictation, or government incompetence. Those answers miss the actual mechanics driving the pump price.

Is the government making massive profits on petrol?

No. While the state collects significant revenue per liter through the Petroleum Development Levy, those funds do not sit in a vault as profit. They are immediately absorbed by debt servicing—which consumes over half of Pakistan’s federal budget—and by circular debt losses across the power and gas sectors. The state is not hoarding cash; it is desperately trying to prevent sovereign default.

Would leaving the IMF make fuel cheaper?

It would do the exact opposite. Without an IMF umbrella, Pakistan loses access to multilateral financing from the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank, and bilateral rollovers from Gulf allies. Without those dollar inflows, the Pakistani rupee would plummet against the dollar. Since oil is priced in dollars, a weaker rupee instantly makes imported fuel vastly more expensive—even if taxes were cut to zero.

Why don't refineries just lower their margins?

Refinery margins and Oil Marketing Company (OMC) commissions represent a tiny fraction of the final retail price—typically a few rupees per liter. Even if every OMC in Pakistan operated as a non-profit charity tomorrow, the relief at the pump would barely register against global crude fluctuations and exchange rate movements.

The Real Structural Rot Nobody Protests

If Jamaat-e-Islami and other opposition groups truly wanted to lower the energy burden on ordinary Pakistanis permanently, they would stop marching over the price of petrol and start marching over structural inefficiencies that bleed billions of dollars every year.

1. The Transport and Logistics Trap

Pakistan moves over 90% of its freight by road using aging, fuel-inefficient trucks burning high-speed diesel, while Pakistan Railways—a far cheaper, bulk-transport alternative—remains chronically underfunded and mismanaged. Every time diesel rises, food inflation spikes because the country lacks functional rail freight corridors. Demanding cheaper diesel instead of modernizing rail logistics locks the economy into permanent vulnerability.

2. Circular Debt and Power Sector Theft

The anger over petrol is amplified by unbearable electricity bills. Yet electricity is expensive not merely because of fuel inputs, but because distribution companies (DISCOs) lose hundreds of billions of rupees annually to technical losses, unpaid bills, and outright theft. Honest, bill-paying citizens are effectively paying a surcharge to subsidize power thieves and inefficient state-owned generation plants.

3. Untaxed Real Estate and Retail

By parking capital in unproductive land plots rather than export-oriented manufacturing, Pakistan’s elite starves the country of the dollar-generating industries needed to pay for energy imports. Until capital is taxed out of speculative real estate and pushed into productive exports, every global commodity cycle will trigger another balance-of-payments crisis.

The Downside of Fiscal Orthodoxy

Acknowledging economic reality does not mean ignoring the human wreckage caused by austerity. Relying exclusively on regressive indirect taxes like fuel levies carries severe economic and social costs that policymakers routinely underestimate.

First, punishing energy taxes destroy demand across legitimate formal businesses. Factories shut down shifts, small logistics operators go bankrupt, and middle-class families pull children out of private schools to pay utility bills. You cannot tax an economy into growth if you suffocate the productive sectors keeping it alive.

Second, perpetual austerity without visible governance reform destroys state legitimacy. When citizens see massive levies slapped on their motorbikes while state-owned enterprises bleed billions and official protocols remain untouched, tax compliance collapses into civil defiance.

Third, blunt price hikes hit transport-dependent workers disproportionately hard compared to urban elites who can absorb higher fuel costs or rely on solar installations to escape grid tariffs. Without targeted, transparent cash transfers that actually reach the vulnerable—such as expanding the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) database to cover lower-middle-income urban workers—austerity breeds the exact street instability now paralyzing major cities.

What Actually Fixes the Crisis

If Pakistan wants to break out of its cycle of fuel hikes, strikes, and emergency bailouts, both the government and protest movements need to abandon short-term theater and confront three hard priorities:

  • Replace blanket fuel subsidies with targeted digital transfers: Never subsidize the fuel itself—cheap petrol subsidizes wealthy SUV owners far more than rickshaw drivers. Keep fuel priced at true market cost plus revenue levies, and route relief directly to registered low-income commuters and small commercial transporters via digital wallets.
  • Enforce direct taxation on retail and agriculture: Break the political bargain that shields traders and large landowners from income tax. Every rupee collected from untaxed retail is a rupee that no longer needs to be squeezed out of diesel and electricity.
  • Accelerate urban mass transit and solar net-metering: The only permanent escape from imported oil is burning less of it. Expanding electric bus networks in Karachi, Lahore, and Rawalpindi and removing regulatory friction around distributed solar generation reduces dollar outflows far more effectively than any sit-in ever will.

Protest movements thrive on simple villains and instant demands. Economics offers neither. Until Pakistan’s political class and its street agitators stop fighting over the price at the pump and start dismantling the untaxed, import-addicted system behind it, the strikes will keep coming—and the fuel will keep getting more expensive.

BM

Bella Miller

Bella Miller has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.