Inside the Movement to Rebuild Israeli Settlements in Gaza

Inside the Movement to Rebuild Israeli Settlements in Gaza

Two decades after Israel dismantled its communities and withdrew its military from the Gaza Strip, an organized coalition of nationalist activists, religious Zionists, and sitting cabinet ministers is actively campaigning to reestablish permanent Israeli settlements inside the territory. While Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has publicly stated that permanent resettlement is not an official war goal, the movement has moved beyond fringe rhetoric into logistical planning, public conferences, and political pressure campaigns.

Understanding this push requires looking past soundbites and examining the political mechanics, historical grievances, and security arguments driving it. To its proponents, returning to Gaza is both a biblical mandate and the only viable deterrent against future attacks. To critics—including Israel’s defense establishment, international allies, and Palestinians—it represents a strategic trap that threatens regional diplomacy and violates international law.

The Anatomy of a Comeback

The 2005 disengagement remains an open wound for a specific segment of Israeli society. When Prime Minister Ariel Sharon ordered the evacuation of 21 settlements in Gaza—collectively known as Gush Katif—roughly 8,000 Israelis were removed from their homes, often carried out by soldiers in scenes broadcast globally.

For years, the broader Israeli public viewed the withdrawal as a painful necessity, even as Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007 and launched intermittent rocket fire. That consensus fractured on October 7, 2023. The Hamas-led assault, which killed roughly 1,200 people in Israel and saw 251 taken hostage, provided the settlement movement with its most potent argument in a generation.

Daniella Weiss, a veteran activist and leader of the Nachala settlement movement, has become the public face of this campaign. Speaking at rallies and in media interviews, Weiss and her organization argue that the 2005 withdrawal directly enabled the October 7 attacks by removing an Israeli civilian and military buffer zone. Nachala has spent months drafting blueprints for new communities, complete with neighborhood layouts, agricultural zones, and lists of hundreds of families claiming readiness to move into the territory as soon as the military permits it.

This is not merely a grassroots effort operating on the margins. In January 2024, thousands of activists gathered in Jerusalem for a conference titled "Settlement Brings Security." The event was attended by a dozen cabinet ministers and Knesset members from Netanyahu’s governing coalition, including National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich. During the gathering, participants danced with maps of proposed Gaza settlements, calling for the encouragement of Palestinian emigration and the re-establishment of Jewish towns across the coastal enclave.

The Political Leverage Behind the Push

To grasp why a concept rejected by a majority of Israelis in public polling commands so much political oxygen, one must look at the arithmetic of Israel’s parliamentary system.

Prime Minister Netanyahu’s coalition relies on the survival of far-right parties, specifically Ben-Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power) and Smotrich’s Religious Zionism. Together, these factions hold enough seats to collapse the government if they withdraw their support. While Netanyahu has repeatedly told international media, including CNN and Fox News, that Israel has no intention of permanently occupying Gaza or resettling its civilian population, his political dependence on these ministers limits his willingness to discipline them when they advocate for the exact opposite.

Smotrich, who holds a dual role as Finance Minister and a minister within the Defense Ministry overseeing civilian affairs in the occupied West Bank, has framed the Gaza issue in terms of permanent control. In speeches and policy discussions, he has argued that without an Israeli civilian presence, the military cannot maintain long-term security control over the strip, warning that Gaza would inevitably revert to a staging ground for militants.

This dynamic creates a strategic ambiguity that serves the settlement movement well. Even without an official cabinet decision authorizing civilian construction in Gaza, the normalization of the idea within government circles shifts the Overton window. What was once dismissed as a political non-starter is now debated on mainstream Israeli television panels and addressed in Knesset committee hearings.

Security Doctrine vs. Ideological Conviction

The debate over Gaza settlements exposes a sharp divide between ideological politicians and Israel’s professional defense establishment.

Proponents of resettlement rely on a foundational principle of early Zionism, often summarized as "where the plow goes, the border follows." In their view, military deployments alone are temporary and vulnerable to international pressure or domestic fatigue. Civilian communities, by contrast, create permanent facts on the ground, anchoring the military to the territory and signaling absolute sovereignty. Activists point to the relative calm in parts of the West Bank compared to the rocket fire from Gaza prior to October 2023 as proof that civilian presence enhances intelligence gathering and operational control.

Senior officials within the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the defense ministry largely reject this premise, viewing civilian settlements inside Gaza as a massive operational liability.

Military analysts and former generals point out that prior to 2005, protecting 8,000 settlers in Gush Katif required thousands of soldiers stationed permanently inside a densely populated hostile environment. Those troops were tied down guarding access roads, escorting school buses, and defending isolated perimeters, stretching military resources thin and exposing soldiers to constant guerrilla attacks. Reintroducing civilians into Gaza—an enclave of more than two million Palestinians, much of it reduced to rubble—would force the IDF to divert combat brigades from border defense and northern fronts to act as static security guards for new outposts.

Furthermore, defense officials warn that pursuing settlement construction undermines Israel's broader strategic alliances. The United States, Israel’s primary military supplier and diplomatic backer, has explicitly opposed any reduction of Gaza’s territory or the re-establishment of settlements. Both the Biden administration and subsequent U.S. foreign policy voices have emphasized that Gaza must remain Palestinian land, warning that settlement expansion would destroy prospects for regional normalization, particularly with Saudi Arabia, and isolate Israel internationally.

International Law and the Legal Reality

Beyond domestic politics and military logistics sits the framework of international law, which views the resettlement push as non-negotiable territory.

Under the Fourth Geneva Convention, an occupying power is prohibited from transferring parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies. The United Nations, the International Court of Justice (ICJ), and the vast majority of the international community consider the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip to be occupied territories, rendering Israeli settlements there illegal under international law.

Israel has historically contested this interpretation regarding the West Bank, arguing that the territory was not under the legitimate sovereignty of another state prior to 1967 and should be classified as "disputed" rather than occupied. Regarding Gaza, the Israeli government maintained after 2005 that its occupation had ended because it had withdrawn all troops and settlers, even though the UN and human rights organizations argued Israel retained effective control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and coastline.

Rebuilding civilian settlements inside Gaza would eliminate any legal ambiguity in the eyes of international courts. Legal experts note that state-backed civilian transfer into Gaza during an active military campaign would immediately expose Israeli officials to heightened scrutiny and potential prosecution at the International Criminal Court (ICC), while severely complicating defense against genocide and war crimes allegations at the ICJ.

The Demographic Question and the "Day After"

Any serious plan to build Israeli communities in Gaza immediately collides with a fundamental demographic reality: what happens to the Palestinians living there?

Gaza is one of the most densely populated areas in the world. Before the war, roughly 2.2 million Palestinians lived within its 141 square miles. Following months of intense bombardment and ground operations, the vast majority of that population has been displaced internally, living in tent camps and damaged infrastructure.

When pressed on how Jewish settlements could coexist with over two million Palestinians, settlement leaders and far-right ministers generally offer one answer: "voluntary migration." Ministers like Ben-Gvir and Smotrich have publicly advocated for incentivizing Palestinians to leave Gaza for third-party countries, framing it as a humanitarian solution that allows civilians to escape a devastated war zone.

Palestinian leaders, neighboring Arab states, and international human rights organizations reject this framing entirely. To Palestinians, any effort to encourage mass departure while simultaneously planning Israeli settlements evokes the Nakba—the 1948 displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians during the creation of Israel. Egypt and Jordan, which border Israel and the Palestinian territories, have repeatedly stated that they will not absorb displaced Gazans, viewing any mass influx as an existential threat to their own national security and a permanent liquidation of the Palestinian national cause.

Without a destination for Gaza's population, establishing Israeli settlements would require either carving out heavily fortified enclaves amid a hostile population of two million people—creating a perpetual low-intensity war—or implementing formal annexation without granting citizenship, a scenario critics warn would cement a system of permanent inequality.

Ground Reality Along the Perimeter

Despite the feverish activity at conferences and in political speeches, the physical reality on the ground remains strictly controlled by the Israeli military.

Since the start of the ground offensive, the IDF has established a buffer zone inside Gaza along the border fence, clearing structures and agricultural land to create a clear line of sight for troops. The military has also bisected the strip along the Netzarim Corridor, a strategic east-west highway south of Gaza City used to control movement between the northern and southern halves of the territory.

For settlement activists, these military infrastructure projects look like the skeleton of a permanent return. Nachala and allied groups have organized border marches, bringing families to the edge of the Gaza perimeter to peer across the fence and hold rallies demanding entry. On several occasions, small groups of activists have briefly breached the border fence to plant trees or erect symbolic wooden structures inside Gaza before being removed by IDF soldiers.

These incidents highlight the tension between the political aspirations of the right and the operational discipline of the military. While the IDF has tolerated rallies near the border, commanders have consistently blocked unauthorized entry, recognizing that allowing civilians into an active combat zone invites immediate casualties and hostage-taking scenarios.

Yet the movement plays a long game. Veteran settlement organizers often note that the post-1967 settlement enterprise in the West Bank did not begin with grand government master plans. It started with small groups of determined activists setting up unauthorized outposts in trailers on rocky hilltops, daring successive Israeli governments to evict them, and gradually securing military protection, water hookups, and eventual state recognition.

By recruiting families now, mapping out future neighborhoods, and keeping the issue alive in the media, the Gaza settlement movement is attempting to replicate that exact playbook. They are betting that prolonged military control over Gaza—a likely scenario given the lack of a viable alternative governing authority—will eventually wear down political resistance and turn temporary military buffer zones into permanent civilian footprints.

Whether that bet pays off depends less on the fervor of the activists and more on the geopolitical pressures closing in on Jerusalem. Caught between a domestic coalition partner demanding a return to Gush Katif and international allies demanding a pathway to Palestinian governance, the Israeli government faces a choice that will define the region's borders for decades.

BM

Bella Miller

Bella Miller has built a reputation for clear, engaging writing that transforms complex subjects into stories readers can connect with and understand.