Inside the Balochistan Crisis Nobody Is Willing to Touch

Inside the Balochistan Crisis Nobody Is Willing to Touch

Enforced disappearances and suspected extrajudicial killings in Balochistan are not isolated security failures, nor are they accidental byproducts of a messy border war. They are the central operating mechanism of a decades-long counterinsurgency strategy designed to pacify Pakistan's largest, poorest, and most resource-rich province. While state officials frame these operations as necessary anti-terror measures against separatist militants, human rights monitors, local activists, and families of the missing describe a systematic campaign of collective punishment that targets students, journalists, political organizers, and ordinary citizens without warrant or trial.

The numbers tell a grim story, though nobody agrees on the exact count. Human rights organizations like the Voice for Baloch Missing Persons (VBMP) have documented thousands of cases over the past twenty years, while state-appointed commissions acknowledge a fraction of that figure, claiming many alleged victims have either joined militant outfits in the mountains or fled across the border. Regardless of which ledger you trust, the operational pattern remains identical. Men—and increasingly, women—are picked up from their homes, university hostels, or highway checkpoints by plainclothes operatives and uniformed personnel, vanishing into a legal black hole for months or years before turning up either in secret detention centers or as mutilated bodies dumped along remote highways.

The Architecture of Impunity

To understand why this keeps happening, you have to look at the legal and institutional machinery built to protect the perpetrators. In theory, Pakistan’s constitution guarantees the right to a fair trial, protection against arbitrary arrest, and the production of any detainee before a magistrate within 24 hours. In practice, those protections evaporate the moment a vehicle pulls up to a house in Quetta, Turbat, or Khuzdar in the middle of the night.

The Actions (in Aid of Civil Power) Regulation, originally introduced for the northwestern tribal areas, established a precedent for preventive detention without judicial oversight that bled into security operations across the country. Even without formal statutory cover in every district, security agencies operate with de facto immunity. Police stations routinely refuse to register First Information Reports (FIRs) when families try to name intelligence or paramilitary personnel as the abductors. Without an FIR, there is no crime on the books. Without a crime on the books, there is no investigation.

"When the state refuses to record that a person existed at the moment of their arrest, the law ceases to function as a shield and becomes a wall."

The Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances (COIoED), formed in 2011 to address the crisis, has largely functioned as an administrative buffer rather than an instrument of accountability. While the commission has traced thousands of missing individuals—many of whom were quietly released or found in state custody—it has failed to prosecute a single security official for orchestrating an abduction. Families are passed from courtrooms to commission hearings, spending their life savings on legal fees and travel, only to be told their cases are "under verification."

The Shift From Abduction to Stage-Managed Encounters

For years, the dominant pattern in Balochistan was known grimly as "kill and dump." Abducted individuals would disappear into custody, and months later, their bullet-riddled bodies would be discovered in desolate areas, often bearing marks of severe torture. That tactic drew fierce international condemnation and galvanized domestic protests, forcing a tactical evolution.

In recent years, rights groups and local journalists have documented a sharp rise in what they describe as staged encounters—deaths officially recorded as gunfights between security forces and armed insurgents. The sequence of events follows a familiar script. A person is reported missing by their family, protests erupt on social media or outside local press clubs, and days or weeks later, the Counter Terrorism Department (CTD) announces that the individual was killed during an intelligence-based operation against militants.

Take a hypothetical example to see how the bureaucratic cover works in practice. Suppose a university student from Kech district is picked up at a bus terminal by men in unmarked vehicles. His family files a petition in the High Court and joins a sit-in protest. Three weeks later, an official press release states that security forces raided a militant hideout in a neighboring district, came under heavy fire, and killed four "terrorists" in self-defense—one of whom turns out to be the missing student. Because the death is classified as an armed clash, no independent autopsy is conducted, no ballistics report is made public, and the High Court petition is disposed of because the missing person has now been "traced."

This shift accomplishes two objectives simultaneously. It clears the backlog of active missing-person cases that attract judicial scrutiny, and it allows the state to categorize political dissidents and suspected sympathizers as active combatants killed in lawful operations.

Why Balochistan Matters So Much to Islamabad

You cannot separate the human rights crisis in Balochistan from the dirt beneath it. Covering roughly 44 percent of Pakistan’s landmass while holding less than 6 percent of its population, the province sits atop massive reserves of natural gas, copper, gold, coal, and chromite. It also holds 750 kilometers of coastline along the Arabian Sea, including the deep-water port of Gwadar, the crown jewel of the multi-billion-dollar China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).

For decades, Baloch nationalists have argued that the central government extracts the province's wealth while leaving its people in abject poverty. Sui, the town where Pakistan’s largest natural gas field was discovered in 1952, did not receive piped gas for its own residents for decades—even as that gas powered factories and homes in Punjab and Sindh. Today, Balochistan still records the lowest literacy rates, highest maternal mortality, and worst multidimensional poverty indicators in the country.

💡 You might also like: The Stone That Breathes Again

When locals demand a greater share of royalties, local employment on mega-projects, or political autonomy, Islamabad views those demands through a hard security lens. The presence of active armed separatist groups—such as the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) and the Balochistan Liberation Front (BLF)—gives the state a permanent justification for militarization. These militant outfits have carried out deadly attacks on security forces, infrastructure, and foreign nationals, including Chinese engineers working on CPEC projects.

The tragedy is that the state’s counterinsurgency apparatus rarely distinguishes between armed insurgents in the hills and peaceful critics in the cities. A student handing out pamphlets, a poet writing in Balochi, or a lawyer defending detainees is treated as part of the same subversive ecosystem as a fighter planting an improvised explosive device.

The Counter-Argument From the Security Establishment

To present a complete picture, you have to understand how the Pakistani military and intelligence establishment view the conflict. From their perspective, they are fighting a brutal, asymmetric war in rugged, sparsely populated terrain bordered by unstable regions in Iran and Afghanistan.

Security officials argue that militant groups exploit the legal system to protect their operatives. According to this line of reasoning, when an insurgent is arrested through standard police procedures, witnesses are too terrified to testify, judges face threats, and the suspect is quickly released on bail—only to return to the mountains and attack military convoys. Military planners also point to foreign intelligence interference, alleging that hostile external actors fund, arm, and shelter Baloch separatists to sabotage CPEC and destabilize Pakistan from within.

In the eyes of the security establishment, conventional policing cannot survive in an environment where militants assassinate local informants and blow up railway tracks. Preventive detention and aggressive intelligence operations are seen as grim necessities to prevent the province from sliding into full-scale territorial loss.

That argument has a fatal flaw, however. Even if you accept the premise that conventional courts struggle to prosecute hardened militants, enforced disappearances do not weaken the insurgency—they recruit for it. Every time a young man is dragged out of his home without charge, his brothers, cousins, and classmates lose whatever remaining faith they had in constitutional politics. Militant commanders do not need sophisticated propaganda when the state’s own tactics serve as their most effective recruitment tool.

A New Generation of Resistance

For twenty years, the face of the anti-disappearance movement in Balochistan was Mama Qadeer, an elderly activist who walked thousands of kilometers from Quetta to Islamabad with families of the missing, carrying faded photographs of vanished sons and husbands. The protests were persistent, tragic, and largely ignored by the national press in Lahore and Karachi.

That dynamic shattered recently with the rise of a younger, sharper, and predominantly female leadership, exemplified by figures like Dr. Mahrang Baloch and the Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC). Unlike earlier nationalist movements fractured by tribal rivalries and ideological disputes, this new wave has built a mass civil rights mobilization rooted in constitutional demands and public visibility.

In late 2023 and throughout 2024, following the alleged extrajudicial killing of a young man named Balaach Mola Bakhsh in CTD custody in Turbat, thousands of protesters marched from Balochistan to the heart of Islamabad. Women led the columns, facing water cannons, mass arrests, and state-backed media smears without breaking discipline. They did not demand secession from the podium; they demanded the right to life, due process, and an end to enforced disappearances.

The state’s response revealed how deeply rattled the establishment had become by peaceful mobilization. Instead of engaging with the protesters' grievances, authorities erected shipping containers to block highways, filed sedition and terrorism charges against peaceful organizers, and disrupted mobile internet services across entire districts to prevent live broadcasts from reaching the outside world.

The Media Blackout and Information Control

One reason the Balochistan crisis remains poorly understood outside the region is the near-total information blockade enforced on mainstream Pakistani media. Major television networks and newspapers operate under strict, unwritten red lines when covering security operations in the province.

Journalists who report independently on missing persons or criticize military operations face accreditation revocation, financial pressure on their outlets, or personal intimidation. Local reporters in districts like Turbat, Panjgur, and Awaran work in an impossible vise—pressured by security agencies to bury stories of state abuses, and threatened by militant groups if they publish official military press releases uncritically. As a result, news from Balochistan reaches the wider world primarily through citizen journalists on encrypted messaging apps and social media platforms, where verification is difficult and state trolls routinely flood timelines with disinformation.

Why International Pressure Rarely Sticks

Western governments and international human rights bodies periodically issue statements expressing concern over enforced disappearances in Pakistan. The United Nations Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances has hundreds of pending cases from Balochistan on its docket. Yet diplomatic statements rarely translate into meaningful leverage.

Geopolitics always wins. Western capitals rely on Islamabad for regional counterterrorism cooperation, intelligence sharing regarding Afghanistan, and stability in a nuclear-armed nation of over 240 million people. Meanwhile, Beijing—Pakistan’s closest strategic ally and primary investor in Balochistan—views the province strictly through the prism of asset protection. China’s primary concern is ensuring that Pakistani security forces neutralize threats to Chinese workers and infrastructure, regardless of the human rights cost to the local population.

Without external accountability and with domestic courts largely unwilling to confront the military establishment directly, the structural incentives remain unchanged.

The Breaking Point

A counterinsurgency that relies on disappearing its own citizens cannot declare victory; it can only manage a permanent state of low-grade war. Every uninvestigated abduction deepens the alienation of an entire generation that has grown up knowing the Pakistani state only through checkpoints, curfews, and funeral prayers. Until legal accountability replaces impunity—starting with the immediate production of all detainees before civilian courts, the dismantling of secret detention facilities, and independent judicial inquiries into every suspected extrajudicial killing—the cycle of violence in Balochistan will continue to escalate, consuming the very stability the state claims it is trying to protect.

EG

Emma Garcia

As a veteran correspondent, Emma Garcia has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.