Ian McEwan Thinks the 22nd Century Will Forget Us (And He Is Right)

Ian McEwan Thinks the 22nd Century Will Forget Us (And He Is Right)

In his novel What We Can Know, Ian McEwan flips the standard dystopian script on its head. Rather than imagining a 22nd century ruled by omniscient machines that remember every keystroke we ever made, he posits an era of profound historical amnesia where scholars struggle to reconstruct the early twenty-first century from corrupted servers, degraded storage media, and the wreckage of climate-battered infrastructure. Most coverage of McEwan’s premise treats it as a clever literary parlor trick. It is not. The Booker Prize winner has stumbled onto an uncomfortable engineering and economic reality that archivists, data scientists, and historians have been warning about for two decades. We are currently living through the most documented era in human history, yet we are leaving behind less durable evidence of our existence than the Sumerians did with wet clay.

The core tension of What We Can Know rests on a simple paradox. When an empire falls or a society contracts, paper burns slowly and stone endures, while magnetic tape demagnetizes in thirty years and cloud servers go dark the moment someone stops paying the electricity bill. McEwan’s 22nd-century researchers are not battling censorship or authoritarian memory holes. They are battling entropy, proprietary file formats, and the quiet rot of silicon.

The Myth of the Permanent Cloud

Talk to any tech executive in Silicon Valley and they will sell you immortality by the gigabyte. Upload your photos, your emails, your drafts, and your financial ledgers to the cloud, and they will sit there forever, backed up across redundant data centers in Oregon, Virginia, and Ireland. That promise relies on a massive unspoken assumption. It assumes uninterrupted global capitalism, cheap baseline energy, stable geopolitics, and corporate continuity for the next hundred years.

History laughs at that assumption.

Take a look at the actual lifespan of the physical media holding our civilization together right now. Enterprise hard drives typically fail within five to seven years. Solid-state drives, the backbone of modern laptops and data centers, store data by trapping electrons in floating-gate transistors; left unpowered in a drawer or an abandoned server farm, those electrons leak away, causing bit rot within a decade. Even archival-grade optical discs degrade as their organic dyes break down.

Consider a hypothetical scenario set in the year 2126, right inside the timeline McEwan explores. A team of researchers at a coastal university—now relocated twenty miles inland due to sea-level rise—recovers an intact server rack from a flooded municipal archive in London. The aluminum chassis survived. The copper wiring is corroded, though salvageable. Yet when engineers pull the solid-state drives and apply power, they find nothing but randomized noise. The electrical charges that represented millions of birth certificates, court transcripts, and private letters dissipated back in the 2050s when the regional grid went offline for eighteen months.

McEwan understands this physical vulnerability better than most futurists. Throughout his career, from Atonement to Machines Like Me, he has obsessed over how human memory distorts the past. In What We Can Know, he scales that obsession up to the civilizational level. The failure is no longer psychological. It is infrastructural.

Why Digital Dark Ages Happen Without a Single Book Burning

Vint Cerf, one of the fathers of the internet, famously warned that the twenty-first century risks becoming a digital dark age. When we moved from physical artifacts to digital streams, we traded durability for convenience. A nineteenth-century novelist left behind boxes of handwritten manuscripts, corrected galley proofs, and carbon copies of letters sent to editors. Literary scholars can trace the exact evolution of Charles Dickens’s sentences by looking at the ink crossings-out on surviving rag paper.

Now look at how a modern writer works.

Drafts live in autosaving cloud documents that overwrite previous versions every few seconds. Correspondence happens in encrypted messaging apps set to vanish after seven days, or inside corporate email servers that automatically purge accounts once an employee leaves or a company gets acquired. Even when files survive, they are locked inside proprietary ecosystems. Try opening a complex multimedia file created in 1998 using software from a defunct startup. Without specialized emulation environments, that file is a brick of unreadable binary code.

We already have proof of how fast modern culture evaporates. In 2019, Myspace admitted that a faulty server migration permanently destroyed twelve years of user-uploaded music—roughly fifty million tracks by fourteen million artists. Nobody burned a library. Nobody dropped a bomb on a data center. A routine technical error wiped out an entire musical subculture overnight, and there were no physical backups to restore it.

McEwan’s fiction extrapolates that exact mechanism across a century of compounding crises. In a world stressed by resource scarcity, coastal inundation, and political fragmentation, maintaining backwards compatibility for obsolete software formats becomes a luxury nobody can afford. Future historians looking back at the 2020s will encounter link rot on a massive scale, where academic citations point to dead domains and primary sources sit behind defunct authentication walls.

The Epistemological Trap in McEwan’s Fiction

What elevates What We Can Know above standard post-apocalyptic fare is its focus on epistemology—the study of how we know what we claim to know. When primary sources vanish, conjecture fills the vacuum. McEwan has spent decades dissecting how partial information leads smart people to catastrophic misunderstandings. In Atonement, a young girl witnesses a fragment of an adult interaction, misinterprets the context, and ruins two lives with her certainty.

Apply that same dynamic to the 22nd century.

Imagine future scholars trying to understand the politics, art, or daily life of our decade using only the fragments that survive the collapse of legacy platforms. If 90 percent of our cultural output disappears into dead servers, the remaining 10 percent takes on distorted, almost mythical weight. An ironic internet meme divorced from its social context reads like sincere religious dogma. A fragmented corporate database becomes the sole surviving record of an entire city’s demographics.

There is a bitter irony here that McEwan exploits with surgical precision. Our era generates more raw data every forty-eight hours than humanity produced from the dawn of civilization until the year 2003. Yet volume is the enemy of preservation. Archivists call this the appraisal crisis. In previous centuries, scarcity forced curation; paper and printing were expensive, so societies preserved what they valued most. Today, because storage appears cheap, we keep everything indiscriminately—millions of duplicate selfies, automated spam logs, trivial notifications—burying the truly significant artifacts under an avalanche of digital junk. When the power goes out or storage budgets get slashed, the wheat and the chaff vanish together.

The Business Model of Erasure

To understand why McEwan’s vision feels so plausible, you have to follow the money. Data preservation is not a technical problem; it is an economic one. Nobody makes quarterly profits by ensuring a file created today remains readable in 2130.

Modern technology companies operate on planned obsolescence and subscription models. Software shifts from owned licenses to rented access. Media shifts from physical discs and downloaded files to streaming rights that expire the moment a licensing deal falls apart. When a streaming platform removes an original film or series to claim a tax write-off, that work ceases to exist legally and, in many cases, practically. If no physical copies were ever pressed, the cultural artifact is dead.

Even institutional memory is fragile. Major news organizations have migrated their archives online multiple times over the last thirty years, losing millions of articles, photographs, and correction logs along the way due to broken content management systems. Academic journals lock vital research behind paywalls managed by conglomerates whose long-term survival is far from guaranteed.

McEwan’s 22nd-century setting forces readers to confront the fragility of digital sovereignty. We do not own our books, our music, our films, or even our personal correspondence. We lease access to them from private corporations whose primary fiduciary duty is to shareholders, not to posterity. If those corporations go bankrupt, pivot their business models, or fall victim to state-sponsored cyberattacks, the historical record evaporates with their market cap.

What Survives When the Grid Falters

If McEwan is right—and the physics of data storage suggests he is—what actually makes it across the century mark into the 22nd century?

Paradoxically, the oldest technologies remain the most reliable. Acid-free rag paper, stored in dry, cool conditions, easily lasts five hundred years without requiring a single watt of electricity or a software update. Microfilm, long mocked by tech evangelists as a relic of dusty library basements, has a verified life expectancy of half a millennium and can be read with nothing more sophisticated than a magnifying glass and a flashlight.

Meanwhile, the cutting edge of long-term archiving is looking backward for inspiration. Projects like the Arctic World Archive in Svalbard store critical cultural and scientific data on specialized photosensitive film buried deep inside a decommissioned coal mine in the permafrost. Researchers at Microsoft and the University of Washington have spent years developing synthetic DNA storage and etched quartz glass plates—technologies designed to mimic the physical permanence of stone tablets while packing in petabytes of information.

Yet these initiatives preserve only a microscopic fraction of human activity. They save the source code of Linux, the text of Wikipedia, and select national treasures. They do not save the texture of everyday life—the messy, uncurated emails, the local news reports, the mid-list novels, the regional music scenes, and the private diaries that allow future generations to feel what it was actually like to be alive right now.

McEwan’s genius lies in recognizing that the loss of those ordinary details changes the very nature of human identity. Without a reliable mirror of the past, the future loses its ability to measure its own progress or recognize its own mistakes.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Legacy

Writers have always been obsessed with immortality, though few admit it openly. For centuries, publishing a book meant launching a physical object into the world that could outlive its author by generations. You could walk into a secondhand shop in Edinburgh or Chicago, pull a battered paperback off a shelf, and commune directly with a mind from fifty or a hundred years ago.

That pipeline is breaking.

By framing What We Can Know around the limits of 22nd-century knowledge, McEwan holds a mirror up to our current arrogance. We assume that because we can search the world’s information in milliseconds today, that information is permanently secured. We confuse instant accessibility with permanence. They are opposites. The very mechanisms that make digital information effortless to copy, transmit, and search—its weightlessness, its dependence on active electrical currents, its entanglement with proprietary code—are the exact mechanisms that guarantee its eventual disappearance.

Future historians will not look back at the early twenty-first century and marvel at our technological omniscience. They will squint at corrupted metadata, broken hyperlinks, and dead hard drives, piecing together our lives from the few physical books, concrete ruins, and stray microfilms that survived the rot. They will know far less about us than we know about the Victorians, and they will spend their careers arguing over the blank spaces we left behind.

EG

Emma Garcia

As a veteran correspondent, Emma Garcia has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.